This is a sample scorecard - none of this data is recorded.
If you have been assigned a review, please click here to log in and complete your review.

Assignment details

Completion deadline: Tuesday, June 27 2017, 6:35pm

To assist you in this review, please use the following resources as references.

Author sample scorecard
An example of the report we send back to the author
Download
Reviewer guide
Directions for completing a Rubriq review
Download

Please check the items that apply, and a suggested score will appear next to each section. You may adjust these scores by dragging the marker up and down the scale. If none of the items apply, select “Meets all criteria” Please provide comments explaining your score in the text boxes found in every section. When you have finalized your scores and comments, click “Submit Scorecard” to complete your review (every section must be complete for the form to submit properly). This form autosaves every 30 seconds.

Quality of Research*

Hypothesis, Objective, Rationale


10

    Methods and Data


    10

      Interpretation


      10


        Quality of Presentation*

        Title, abstract, and introduction


        10

          Results (text)


          10

            Results (figures, graphs, and tables)


            10

              Discussion


              10

                Conclusions


                10

                  References


                  10

                    Writing


                    10


                      Novelty & Interest*

                      Novelty


                      10

                      New technique, method, or approach (proof of principle)

                      New question, theory or hypothesis (totally new idea)

                      New result, discovery, or perspective/synthesis (proves an established idea)

                        Interest


                        10


                          Publication Potential

                          Considering novelty, interest, and subject matter, what journals do you believe would be most likely to publish a revised version of this manuscript?



                            Sound Research*

                            Disregarding any consideration of novelty, does this work represent technically sound research?



                              Please leave comments below about your overall impression or the potential impact of the manuscript. *

                              When you have finalized your scores and comments, please click 'Submit Scorecard' below.